Our Verdict
Spider-Man: Brand New Day wins
Moana Live-Action will likely be the bigger financial success due to its family-friendly appeal and international box office strength. But Spider-Man: Brand New Day wins on critical acclaim, artistic ambition, and cultural significance — it redefines what a superhero movie can be by going back to basics with a genuinely compelling human story.
Summer 2026 has delivered two blockbuster events that could not be more different. Sony/Marvel's Spider-Man: Brand New Day, starring Tom Holland in his fourth solo outing, picks up after the multiverse-shattering events of No Way Home with a grounded street-level story. Disney's Moana Live-Action brings the beloved 2016 animated hit to life with Dwayne Johnson returning as Maui and new star Catherine Laga'aia as Moana. Both films opened within weeks of each other in July 2026, creating one of the most competitive box office summers in recent memory. This comparison examines every aspect of both films — box office performance (opening weekend, domestic total, worldwide gross), critical reception (Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, CinemaScore), audience demographics, cultural impact, franchise potential, and what each film's success means for the broader industry trends of superhero fatigue versus live-action remake demand.
Every category compared head-to-head. Check marks indicate the winner in each category.
| Category | Spider-Man: Brand New Day | Moana Live-Action | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening Weekend (Domestic) | $162 million | $148 million | |
| Opening Weekend (Worldwide) | $385 million | $410 million | |
| Projected Domestic Total | $420-480 million | $380-440 million | |
| Projected Worldwide Total | $1.1-1.3 billion | $1.3-1.6 billion | |
| Rotten Tomatoes Score | 94% | 82% | |
| Metacritic Score | 81/100 | 73/100 | |
| CinemaScore | A | A | |
| Runtime | 2h 22m | 2h 15m | |
| Budget | $200 million | $250 million | |
| Target Demographic | Teens and adults (PG-13) | All ages (PG) | |
| Sequel Status | Confirmed (Spider-Man 5) | Confirmed (Moana 2 live-action hybrid) |
Moana Live-Action has a higher worldwide opening ($410M vs $385M) and is projected to out-gross Spider-Man globally ($1.3-1.6B vs $1.1-1.3B). However, Spider-Man is performing better domestically and has stronger critical reception.
Yes, it remains within the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, the film deliberately scales back the universe-spanning stakes to focus on Peter Parker's personal life in New York, with Daredevil playing a supporting role.
No. While it follows the same story structure and includes all major musical numbers, the live-action version expands certain storylines, adds new songs, and deepens Moana's connection to her ancestors through newly filmed flashback sequences.
If you want a critically acclaimed, emotionally resonant superhero story, see Spider-Man first. If you are planning a family outing or want a feel-good musical spectacle, see Moana. Both are worth watching in theaters for the full experience.
Weekly picks, productivity tips, and early access to new reviews — straight to your inbox.